Receiving a low home appraisal is a stressful moment for both buyers and sellers, often leaving everyone involved in a state of uncertainty. It’s one of the most common hurdles in a real estate transaction. For homeowners and buyers in Houston, this situation can be especially confusing, leaving them wondering if sellers will lower their price after an appraisal. In this blog post, Houston real estate expert Chris Schmidt discusses what happens when an appraisal comes in low.
No, sellers are not automatically required to lower their price after a low appraisal. It is a common outcome, especially in a buyer’s market, but the final decision is ultimately a negotiation between the buyer and seller. In Houston’s dynamic market, other options like the buyer covering the gap or splitting the difference are also frequent solutions.
Key Takeaways
- Sellers are not obligated to lower their price to the appraised value; it is a point of negotiation.
- In Texas, the TREC Third-Party Financing Addendum includes an appraisal contingency that gives the buyer leverage to negotiate or walk away.
- The most common solutions include the seller lowering the price, the buyer paying the difference in cash, or both parties “splitting the difference.”
- Current market conditions in Houston (whether it’s a seller’s or buyer’s market) will heavily influence a seller’s willingness to negotiate.
To Discuss Your Home Sale or Purchase, Call or Text Today and Start Packing!
What is an Appraisal Gap and Why Does it Happen in Houston?
An “appraisal gap” is the difference between the home’s contracted purchase price (the price the buyer and seller agreed on) and the lower appraised value determined by an independent appraiser. For example, if you agree to buy a home for $400,000, but the appraisal comes in at $390,000, there is a $10,000 appraisal gap.
Lenders will typically only finance a loan based on the appraised value, not the higher contract price. This leaves the buyer to make up that $10,000 difference.
This happens frequently in competitive markets like Houston for a few key reasons:
- Bidding Wars: When multiple buyers compete for a home, it can drive the sales price above what recent comparable sales (comps) can support.
- Rapidly Rising Prices: In a hot market, home values may increase faster than appraisers can account for with historical data.
- Non-Disclosure State: Texas is a “non-disclosure” state, meaning home sale prices are not public record. Appraisers must rely on MLS data, which can sometimes be incomplete, making it harder to find accurate comps.
The 5 Most Common Outcomes After a Low Appraisal
When an appraisal comes in low, the deal is not automatically dead. It simply opens a new round of negotiations. Here are the most common outcomes:
- The Seller Lowers the Price: The seller agrees to reduce the home’s price to the appraised value. This is common when the seller is motivated, or in a more balanced or buyer’s market.
- The Buyer Covers the Gap: The buyer pays the difference in cash at closing. In our $400,000 example, the buyer would bring an extra $10,000 to the table on top of their down payment. This often happens in strong seller’s markets.
- Buyer and Seller Split the Difference: This is a common compromise. The seller might agree to lower the price by $5,000, and the buyer agrees to bring an extra $5,000 in cash.
- The Appraisal is Challenged: The buyer (or their lender) can submit a “Reconsideration of Value.” This involves providing the appraiser with new, more accurate comps or pointing out factual errors in the report. This is not always successful but is a possible option.
- The Contract is Canceled: If no agreement can be reached, and the buyer has an appraisal contingency, they can typically walk away from the deal and have their earnest money returned.
The Texas-Specific Factor: The TREC Appraisal Contingency
In Texas, the most important tool for navigating a low appraisal is the TREC Third-Party Financing Addendum. This form is attached to most contracts involving a mortgage. It includes an appraisal contingency that allows the buyer to terminate the contract (and keep their earnest money) if the property does not appraise for a specified value.
This contingency is the buyer’s primary source of leverage. Because a seller knows the buyer can walk away without penalty, they are often more motivated to come to the negotiating table and find a solution, which frequently involves lowering the price.
“In Texas, the appraisal contingency in the TREC financing addendum is the single most important tool in this situation. It protects the buyer and sets the stage for a professional negotiation, which is where an experienced agent makes all the difference.” – Chris Schmidt
How Market Conditions Influence a Seller’s Decision
A seller’s willingness to lower their price depends heavily on the current real estate market.
- In a Seller’s Market: When inventory is low and demand is high, sellers have all the power. If a seller has multiple backup offers, they have very little incentive to lower their price. They will likely ask the buyer to cover the entire gap or move on to the next offer.
- In a Buyer’s Market: When inventory is high and sales are slow, the power shifts to the buyer. A seller is much more likely to lower their price to save the deal rather than risk putting their home back on the market, where it could sit for weeks.
After a Low Appraisal: Who Has the Power?
| Possible Outcome |
Seller’s Market (Low Inventory / High Demand) |
Buyer’s Market (High Inventory / Low Demand) |
|---|---|---|
| Seller Lowers Price Seller agrees to the new, lower appraised value to save the deal. | UNLIKELY | HIGHLY LIKELY |
| Buyer Covers the Gap Buyer brings extra cash to closing to make up the difference. | HIGHLY LIKELY | UNLIKELY |
| Buyer & Seller Split Both parties compromise, meeting somewhere in the middle. | COMMON | COMMON |
| Deal is Canceled Buyer uses their TREC contingency to walk away and find another home. | POSSIBLE |
POSSIBLE (Buyer has high leverage) |
We are currently seeing a more balanced market in Houston. Sellers who understand this are more willing to negotiate on a low appraisal to keep a solid deal together. Factors like new construction in suburbs like Katy or The Woodlands can also affect inventory, further influencing negotiations. This is why working with the best realtor to help sell a house is crucial. An expert understands the nuances of the Houston market and its many neighborhoods. The Houston Association of Realtors (HAR) provides guidance on navigating these gaps, but an agent’s on-the-ground experience is invaluable.
“We’re seeing a more balanced market in Houston. Sellers who understand this are more willing to negotiate on a low appraisal to keep a solid deal together rather than risking a return to the market.” – Chris Schmidt
Why Choose Chris Schmidt to Navigate Appraisal Negotiations
When a low appraisal threatens to derail your home sale or purchase, you need an expert negotiator on your side. Chris Schmidt and his team at Your Home Sold Guaranteed Realty - Chris Schmidt Team have nearly two decades of experience navigating complex transactions in the Houston market. We understand the TREC contracts inside and out and use our market knowledge to protect your interests, whether you are a buyer or a seller.
Our clients’ success is backed by hundreds of 5-Star Google reviews and unique guarantees, like our “You Will Love Your New Home or I’ll Buy It Back” Guarantee. We have the expertise to help you sell your Houston home or find your dream property, handling challenges like appraisal gaps with professional skill. Don’t leave your biggest investment to chance. Contact us at 713-322-5604.
To Discuss Your Home Sale or Purchase, Call or Text Today and Start Packing!
Follow Us On Social Media
5 Star Google Reviews YouTube Facebook Instagram LinkedIn TikTok
FAQ
If you have an appraisal contingency as part of your financing addendum, you have the right to terminate the contract and get your earnest money back, as long as you do so within the timeframe specified in the contract. If you waived the appraisal contingency, you may be obligated to cover the gap or risk losing your earnest money if you walk away. This is why it’s critical to have an expert from Your Home Sold Guaranteed Realty - Chris Schmidt Team review your contract and advise you before you make an offer.
